‘Saltburn meets The Secret History in this gripping tale of alchemy and academia’ IAN RANKIN

Five friends. One deadly obsession.

The salt-scented quadrangles of St Andrews University greet misfit first-year student Finn Nethercott with indifference. This is a place where only privilege counts, and those from the right backgrounds can get away with murder.

Finn is quickly seduced into a new circle of friends. Four history scholars obsessed with the deepest roots of ancient Scotland. They sweep him away on wild adventures to forgotten castles and faerie lochs.

But he soon discovers the darker sides of his new friendships: deadly rivalries, midnight rituals, and a desperate search for a long-lost hallucinogen.

So what is this book club
and how do I join in?

Together with our friends at Aries Fiction, we are hosting a read along book club on the Novellic app to celebrate the release of this fabulous book. #

You can join in by downloading the Novellic app and joining the When We Were Killers Read Along book club where we will be posting the daily prompts and chatting away about all the plot twists and mysteries as they unfold!

We will email you prompts and discussion topics as we progress through the chapters, and by sharing your thoughts you will also be in with a chance to win a swoon-worthy bookish prize consisting of a St. Andrews swag bag to commemorate the gorgeous setting of the book.

Join the chat!

You’re not on Novellic yet and would still like to join in on the conversation? Use the form below to send us your thoughts on the book and we will add it to the discussion for you. You can also post your thoughts on Instagram using the hashtag #whenwewerekillers and tagging us @beNovellic and your post will show up on the Bookstagram feed!

Reading Plan and Discussion Prompts

Check back daily for the latest discussion prompts as we progress with the book

Prompts:

  • Discuss the initial sense of guilt and tragedy - what do you think happened at the cliff?

  • The prologue hints at deep regret. Did you guess who “she” was by the end of this section?

  • What do you think Madri meant by “he’s just what we’re looking for”? Foreshadowing or manipulation?

  • Were you surprised by Finn’s choice to study Divinity, considering his past?

  • Did you sense something off about the group Madri is with during the fire scene at the castle?

  • When Finn overhears the argument and sees the girl collapse, what did you think had just happened?

  • What do you think the group was really doing at the castle that night — just a ritual, or something more?
  • Did you anticipate Hope’s arrival and the role she would play in the story?

  • The group’s rituals and references to Norse mythology begin to escalate. Did you expect this direction?

  • What do you make of the quiet tension between Magnus and Finn? Foreshadowing something bigger?

  • Did you catch on to the pattern of rituals aligning with ancient calendar events?

What did you think of Finn’s increasing involvement in the group? Is he being initiated or manipulated?

Were you surprised by the secrecy surrounding Magnus’s past? What do you think he's hiding?

What’s your take on the blend of spiritualism, paganism, and academic study happening in the group?

Did you anticipate that the rituals would become physically or psychologically dangerous?

 

  • What did you make of the group’s deepening commitment to the Clan? Did you think it was becoming cult-like?

  • What is your theory about what really happened during the ritual that left the girl unconscious earlier?

  • Do you think Madri and Magnus are being honest about the purpose of the rituals?

  • Did you guess that the group had an internal hierarchy and secret roles?

  • What plot developments surprised you the most in these chapters?

  • Did you expect the group to actually travel to Finlaggan? What did that shift in location signal to you?

  • How did the initiation ceremony affect your understanding of the group’s seriousness?

  • Were you surprised by how much Finn buys into the ritual and its meaning?

  • Do you think the group crossed a line during their time on the island? If so, where?

  • Did you guess the truth about Hope’s past before it was revealed?

  • What new questions were raised for you by the end of this chunk?

 

  • What was your reaction to the ritual that went wrong? Did you see that twist coming?

  • How do you interpret the group’s reaction to the incident? Were you surprised by their choices?

  • What do you think is motivating Finn at this point: loyalty, love, fear, or something else?

  • When the group starts talking about sacrifice and secrecy, what did you think they meant?

  • Did you guess who might become the scapegoat or the target of blame?

  • What part of this section shocked or unsettled you the most?

 

  • Were you surprised at who ends up dead? Did you think it was going to be someone else?

  • Who did you suspect first when the incident occurred? Why?

  • What do you think was actually planned vs. what was spontaneous?

  • Did you expect Finn to go along with it, or did his actions surprise you?

  • What’s your theory on who’s still keeping secrets, even now?

 

  • Were you satisfied with the explanation of what happened the night of the incident?

  • Did you guess the final twist or did it catch you off guard?

  • Who, in your opinion, bears the most guilt?

  • Do you believe Finn found closure by the end? Why or why not?

  • What do you make of the final confrontation/conversation? Did it resolve what needed resolving?

  • Looking back, were there any clues you missed that now seem obvious?

Book Chat from
the Novellic app

cURL error 6: Could not resolve host: apiv3.novellicserver.com

Bookstagram Posts

Shopping Basket